Hiring has become a full-time job most small firms cannot staff

Recruitment has become harder and legally riskier over the past year, yet in most small UK businesses it still has no owner. 

There were 1.42 million businesses with employees in the UK private sector at the start of 2025, according to the Department for Business and Trade’s business population estimates. More than 1.15 million of them employ between one and nine people. A further 220,000 employ between ten and 49. Small and medium-sized firms account for 60% of private sector jobs.

In almost all of those businesses, hiring is done by someone who already has a full-time job.

Who actually does the hiring in a 20-person business

The managing director writes the advert on a Sunday evening. The operations manager sifts CVs between supplier calls and squeezes interviews into whatever gaps the diary allows. References get chased when somebody remembers.

Nobody in that picture is doing anything wrong. They are doing a second job without the time or training for it. The process changes every time a different person runs it.

The pattern is not limited to small firms. The CIPD’s Resourcing and talent planning report 2026, based on a YouGov survey of 1,014 HR decision-makers carried out in April and May, found that 46% of organisations still take an ad hoc approach to recruitment. Only 31% track how long it takes them to hire. In a business without an HR team, the true figure is unlikely to be better.

More applicants, fewer people worth interviewing

For most small employers the problem is not a shortage of applications.

The same CIPD survey found that 58% of employers had seen more applications from unsuitable candidates over the past year, while just 33% had seen more from suitable ones. Over half (53%) of the organisations that tried to recruit had difficulty attracting candidates, particularly for senior and skilled roles.

The latest KPMG and REC UK Report on Jobs, published on 9 November with data collected in the second half of October, shows the same split. Candidate availability rose sharply, which recruiters put down to redundancies and fewer openings. In the same month they reported that high-calibre candidates were often in short supply. Starting salaries rose as employers competed for them.

Permanent placements also fell for the first time in four months. Maxine Bligh, interim chief executive of the Recruitment and Employment Confederation, said that “faced with economic uncertainty at home and abroad and increased costs and risks of employment, many employers are taking a more cautious approach.”

For an owner-manager, that combination is the hardest version of the job. The inbox fills up while the shortlist stays thin. Every hour spent reading unsuitable CVs is an hour not spent finding the two people who would actually do well in the role.

Why a poor hire will cost more from January

The legal stakes are rising too.

From 1 January 2027, the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal claims falls from two years to six months, according to the government’s published timeline for the Employment Rights Act 2025. The cap on compensatory awards for unfair dismissal is also being removed. The government intends employees who already have six months’ service on that date to be covered straight away. The time limit for bringing an Employment Tribunal claim has already doubled from three months to six, since 1 October 2026.

For a small employer this changes the arithmetic of a mistake. Under the old rules there were two years to notice that a hire was not working and deal with it. From January there will be six months.

That puts the weight back on the parts of recruitment that small firms tend to rush. A clear job description, a structured interview and properly checked references matter more when there is less time to correct a wrong decision afterwards. So does a probation period that someone actually manages.

The options for a firm that hires every month

Businesses that hire once or twice a year can usually manage with a careful in-house process, provided one named person owns it and has time set aside for it. The difficulty starts when hiring becomes continuous.

Many then turn to recruitment agencies. Agencies work well for a one-off specialist role. Across a steady flow of permanent hires the fees add up. Each agency also runs its own process to its own standard.

Others hand over the whole process instead. Under recruitment process outsourcing, or RPO, a specialist provider runs sourcing, screening, assessment, offers and onboarding as one managed service, usually under the employer’s own brand.

The model is usually aimed at businesses with a regular volume of permanent hires rather than an occasional vacancy. UK provider Omni RMS sets out how a full-service arrangement works at www.omnirms.com/rpo-recruitment/end-to-end-rpo, including the situations where a project-based model would suit better.

Whichever route a business chooses, the starting point is the same. Someone has to own the hiring plan and answer for how long each hire takes.

The unfair dismissal changes take effect on 1 January 2027. Anyone a business takes on this month will reach six months’ service in May.

Photo Credit: Pexels.

You May Also Like

Must Read

Skip to content